— #SWCC Star Wars Authentics (@Topps) April 11, 2019
It was this cryptic tweet which sent a certain sector of the online card collecting community into an absolute tizzy Thursday night. The implication that the cult-favorite Topps Total product would be returning to store shelves sometime this year is enough to make many a low budget collector dance for joy. I, for one, was tempted to run down my street while joyfully announcing the news to my confused neighbors.
The basis of the original Total brand was to provide a broader look into the playing rosters for baseball, basketball, football, and - briefly - hockey teams in any given year. When it comes to baseball, that meant an incredibly large, one-shot checklist of over 900 glorious cards, which featured the likes of backup catchers, utility infielders, middle relievers and Quad-A in-betweeners who are all-too-often ignored by Topps' Flagship and other numerous products. This all-encompassing set featured a few inserts and parallels; but, all in all, the focus was certainly on properly documenting each team's active playing roster as best as possible. Running from 2002 through 2005, Topps Total may very well have been my favorite Topps product of all-time.
Why is that you might ask? Well, if you've ever read Wrigley Roster Jenga, you know that my baseball card collection revolves around the Cubs' all-time roster. My Cubs' All-Time Roster Collection, in which I attempt to obtain one card of every man to ever suit up in Cubbie Blue, has been my main focus for more than a decade, was what inspired me to start this blog in the first place (to document my progress), and is the most treasured binder on my shelf. Therefore, with that collecting goal in mind, it shouldn't come as a surprise that such a product would be so important to me and my niche compilation of cardboard.
Total's original run produced rare Cubs cards (sometimes the only known examples) of several cameo Cubbies in my collection, including, but not limited to:
Alan Benes (2002-03)...
...and guys who I have yet to track down in the wild, like Kent Mercker (2004) and Pat Mahomes (2002) - the journeyman pitcher, not his star quarterbacking son. Thanks to the Trading Card Database for the illustrative scans - if you have spares of these particular cards lying around, I'd love to talk trade.
In fact, in one case, Topps Total is responsible for the only known Big League cards WHATSOEVER of a 14-year MLB veteran. Believe it or not, it's the god's honest truth.
Ron Mahay, who was born and raised almost next-door to me in Crestwood, IL, appeared in Major League games from 1997 through 2010, and yet he never appeared on a single non-Total pasteboard. The 2004 piece and it's compatriot from 2005 are Ron's only Major League documentation to come in a traditional format (though there are some oddballs floating around). Strange, right?
The reason for this slight is really quite simple, Ron Mahay was a scab - he served as a replacement player during the player's strike of 1994-95 and crossed the picket line to attend spring camp with the Red Sox. As a result, Mahay was banned from the MLB Players' Union and thus kept out of all events and products associated with their licensing. Of course this never changed for Mahay (or any of his fellow picket-crossers), so I don't know why the shun was lifted for two years of Total and only Total; however, I sure am glad that Topps gave a little bit. After all, though it may be a Rangers card, with such an odd circumstance, I'm lucky to have any card of the 2001 Cubs reliever for my CATRC, let alone a Cubs one.
As you can see, Total may have only been around for a scant four years, but it has continued to be an invaluable resource for my most hallowed collection. Needless to say, I was absolutely pumped up to see that the product was making a grand return.
Well... I was, anyway. Then, Topps released the details...
2019 Topps Total Baseball details, checklist and team set lists (for #1-100 of 900): https://t.co/2XBma312x5 pic.twitter.com/suhSl7uIwL— Ryan Cracknell (@tradercracks) April 12, 2019
I'll let Ryan Cracknell handle the overview - feel free to pause here and read his article about the "Total package." If you don't want to take the time, I'll distill it down to the nitty gritty - they've turned Total into some quasi-high end BS.
The concept is still the same - a 900 card checklist which shines the spotlight on each team's roster, from top to bottom. However, this is where the path begin to diverge from the source material. This time around, it's only going to be baseball because, you know, license exclusivity. The set has been broken down into waves (nine in all) of 100 cards each and will only be available for a set amount of time. You know what that means: you won't be finding these cards on the shelves of your LCS or the aisle-ways of Target and Walmart. Total will only be available online. In my eyes, this is a bit of a downer, but not a total deal-breaker. I'd much rather be able to swing by a shop and pick up a few packs of my primo product; but, this is the 21st century and all. Online shopping my preferred avenue, though it is not the main problem in this situation.
Here's the thing, the OG Total was a low-end, set-builder focused product with packs of ten cards selling for about $1.50, as I recall. The revived version will also feature packs of ten cards - through the Topps website, of course - with a price tag of... wait for it.... $10.
That's right, ten bucks for just ten cards... a dollar per card. That's insane!
While the price falls in line with most of Topps' other "on-line only" products like Now and the Living Set, in those cases, the buyer knows exactly what they are getting when that box shows up on their doorstep. For Total, we have to slap down an Alexander Hamilton for a ten-card, lottery scratch off in the hopes that we end up with the cards that we desire. If I not lucky enough to pull my Daniel Descalso (the only person making their Cubs debut, according to the 2019 Total Wave One Checklist), in the first overpriced pack, it could cost me upwards of $20 just to snag this base card? No thank you.
Now if there were a way to purchase team sets or do some sort of subscription service for this bastardized version of Total, I might still consider partaking. That said, ten dollars for a pack is a price point that is simply ludicrous. Hopefully the singles show up for cheap on the secondary market, as investors and breakers are the only people ready to jump at that rate.
I guess I'll just have to make my own....
Anyway, those are my thoughts on the matter, what are yours? I invite you to share how you feel about these developments in the comment section below. Do you think that Topps is gauging collectors with this pricing? Does the online exclusivity bother you more than it does I? Do you find this all to be perfectly reasonable? Do you even share the same warm-fuzzies about Total that I do? I implore you to weigh-in on the matter on this post as I am quite curious how my fellow collectors feel about all of this.
In my humble opinion, this turned out to be a Total letdown.





















































